Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
really tvtorrents.com
that site removes any content that has not aired on tv
direct to dvd stuff like bsg the plan are not allowed until they air on tv (and therefore fall under the fair use doctrine of timeshifting)
|
look theres a guy selling crack in the ghetto, thus it must be legal.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
fuck nut, you have a right to timeshift copyright protected content.
|
i have never seen any such "right" given, a long ago case was won based on that argument for a vcr, not for torrent sites that profit from the theft of copyright material.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
A tv show that is protected by copyright is legally allowed to be timeshifted. With a VCR or a CLOUD.
|
please post proof, highlight the words "legally allowed" , "tv show" , "timeshifted", "vcr" and "cloud" please
i bet you are all talk jack..
Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
given the fact that 99.5% (according to the US census) have at least 1 tv (95% have two tvs or more) that only .5% of the population.
|
and all the shows on tv are free right ? everyone gets every channel free ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
It is interesting how you are calling me on doing the exact same thing as the thread starter
Gotcha
|
actually he didnt try and defend copyright theft with one law and and ignore copyright laws based on another countries law sorry.
Gotcha
Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
fair use rights and the exclusive rights of the copyright holder were granted by the exact same act.
|
and none of them say anything about timeshifting tv shows.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
So why the fuck do you believe that it ok to take away the fair use right that have ALREADY BEEN ESTABLISHED every time a new technology is created to allow you take advantage of that right.
|
well first off i never said anything remotely close to what you just said. Just to be clear.
Nobody is trying to "take away" fair use, timeshifting for yourself should be legal. The problem arises in the "cloud". The "cloud" is vastly different now and we KNOW the cloud is being abused, yes laws should reflect the fact that the "cloud" had very little impact on the revenue of the copyright material in the "cloud" years ago. Now the "cloud" is having a huge impact on the ability for copyright holders to profit from their material.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
The EU is further a head not only making that ruling years before canada, but establish the bases for ACCESS SHIFTING (1 download != 1 lost sale).
|
if i was gonna buy something and instead i download it for free then 1 download = 1 lost sale idiot.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
I have predicted for more than 2 years that US ruling would happen BASED ON THE PREVIOUS RULINGS from CANADA and EU.
|
you should start one of those phone psychic gigs.. you could make alot of money with your abilities.