Shap

I don't know about you guys but a lot of my success has come thanks to help and feedback I received from others. I remember when I started in this biz the leaders at the time were very helpful and instrumental in helping the new breed succeed. So I was thinking of an idea on how to help new or old people in the industry.

We create a site where once a week (or once a month) a site is chosen for the community to give feedback on. The site is listed and then the community provides feedback on it. We have thumbs up and thumbs down on comments so the site owner (and people reading it) can see what advice people agree with most and what advice they disagree with. That way bad feedback gets drowned out and good feedback rises to the top. So even if you don't have time to provide feedback you can contribute by voting on which feedback you agree with.

There could also be a separate section for developers, designers etc to offer their help. I know sometimes it's hard to know how to make the next steps to improve a site or who to go to to get help this could help.

I don't know what do you guys think? Good idea?