Thread: Why The Copyright Industry Isn?t a Legitimate Stakeholder in Copyright
View Single Post
Old 05-01-2011, 10:45 AM  
CrkMStanz
Confirmed User
 
CrkMStanz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 517
Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by Paul Markham
The statement IS protected by the First Amendment. And the Copyright of the clip is protected by another law. So the "should be" statement is stupid.

If the original poster of that clip wants to put it on Youtube with a comment. He has a way of doing so. Contact the copyright holder, obtain his permission and if obtained, post the comment and the clip.

you just violated the bill of rights


Quote:
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech

you made the right to comment (free speech) dependent on a congressionally created exclusive right of control.

you reverse the priority of the two laws

which is exactly the point i am making



Quote:
Your statement can be applied to anything. I can pirate a movie, show it in a cinema and put a comment in the bottom right hand corner saying "great movie". If publishing something protected by copyright is legal so long as it has a comment.

Can I put adverts next to the screen as well?

only if your a moron who doesn't understand how to support fair use and fight piracy at the same time.

Your "RIGHT" to "Free Speech" protects your words and expression of your ideas - not your posting of MY works

so if you want to be protected for your 'commentary' - use words - not a full reposting of my work with a one line comment (or even a 20 page diatribe) - if you want to comment then do it WITHOUT posting my work - fair use allows for a small portion of the original work to be used - not a full re-posting.

your "RIGHT" to free speech does not cover your redistribution of my digital media

and - you pretending that you don't make money off of my work while your profitable advertisements surround the display of MY work is ludicrous at best


.
__________________
believe me - without free porn, just as many people will seek porn out on the Internet, and many more will pay if there is no free alternative, its not like sex is a fad - it can be milked much like any renewable resource - long term

i wasn't born with enough middle fingers - Marilyn Manson
CrkMStanz is offline   Share thread on Digg Share thread on Twitter Share thread on Reddit Share thread on Facebook Reply With Quote