So we worked out the solution with fivestar, so in case you are on CF and want to exclude one page, then the following are the steps to do so:
Code:
1) under CRYPTO disable 'Always use HTTPS'
2) under PAGE RULES add the following rules:
first rule: domain.com/page.html -> SSL OFF
second rule: http://domain.com/* -> ALWAYS USE HTTPS
The first rule has to be the page/directory you want to exclude..