Facebook bans breast-feeding photographs
 

I'm sorry, I just think that's ridiculous! :helpme

Facebook said the pictures violate the company's policy on obscene, pornographic or sexually-explicit material, because of the display of the aureola - the dark skin around the nipple. Reportedly, it had also threatened to terminate accounts of people who do not comply with such policy.

"We agree that breast-feeding is natural and beautiful, and we're very glad to know that it is so important to some mothers to share this experience with others on Facebook," said Facebook spokesman Barry Schnitt.

The company insists it is not about obscenity, but more about safety. The policies are to ensure the site remains safe, secure and trusted by its users, who also include teenagers.

http://digital.asiaone.com/Digital/N...29-111017.html

that does it, closing down my account

Face book is created for college and other students to network and share interests

not for some fat slob to show off her tits under the excuse of it being a "breast feeding" photo, in order to gain "Internet friends"

OR for some porn content shooter to look for new potential models they can stalk in to submission by flashing a $100 bill

That is ridiculous.

But how many mothers have photos taken of them while breast feeding and then want to post them to Facebook?

Good. Who wants to see the lactating titty of some girl from high school 15 years and 30 pounds later...

The whole breast feeding in your face thing is completely obnoxious.

there must be groups of these mothers that want to share their morning sickness and natural child birth stories with each other, it doesn't seem far fetched

facebook is huge and it covers many segments of society, not just the dumb fuck highschoolers :2 cents:

*sigh* Because we know a woman naturally feeding her child is the most obscene thing ever.
Bring on the bpa laced plastic bottles and the doctored cows milk instead. That's just fine.

Tell all the breast-feeding facebooker to post them here :)

Well... it is a slippery slope.. it's for the kids you know...

So is intercourse, whats the difference?

Your brain just goes to porn and money instantly...

You do realize that there's a whole community of hot, crunchy moms who all breast feed and are proud of the all natural lifestyle they are providing their kids...

Sometimes I see you post.. and it's like you have stereotype, dickhead, guy blinders on. You dont see life outside of porn, beer, and money.

Mothers breastfeeding in public is not against the law, sex in public is.

Bottom line, Facebook is a private domain, they can do whatever the fuck they want and make up whatever rules they want.

Sex itself is not either pornographic nor obscene though either. Read their own TOS. Has nothing to do with it being in public. If someone takes a picture in their own home of them having sex and shares it online. No laws have been broken.

Yes it is a private company and they can do what they want. I rather see full universal censorship instead of ala cart censorship on such sites.

I mean, they list the reason as keeping the site safe for the minors.
Breastfeeding is something anyone can legally see in public. Sex is not.

Care not about minors. Sites like facebook should not be for minors anyways. At least craigslist has publicly said they think their site is also not for minors.
Screw the minors. If someone is worried their kid may see someone having sex then facebook let alone the internet is not for them.
To add to the whole damn confusion note that assorted TV channels and such have begun to censor animals having sex as well. Anyone can see that in public as well, but they are already making it dirty by censoring it.

Seriously, why the fuck would anyone post breast-feeding pics?

Girl on my facebook doing this right now and she is pissed of that she is not allowed too.

The hefty pringle stuffing suffragette tyes... and who wants to see their fucking sweaty saggy tits anyway, let alone see some bald headed little fucker getting his hourly mouthful. :error The dumb bitches who feel the need to post up those pics like mother Earth need to get fucking beatdown by a gang of hot teenage lesbians.

However, if it were Sylvia Saint breastfeeding Scarlett Pain, I might complain. :1orglaugh

jesus christ....why not take picture of you shitting tooo and share it on facebook.

No . its YOU who have Zero grasp of the real world.

Facebook is a site for college and other students to network - what part of that dont you fucking understand? how about you wake the fuck up and see things as they are, instead of looking at everything as a service created for you to exploit.

Face book is for students - keep you fat lactating tits out of there

To compare the act of feeding your baby to shitting. Jesus fucking Christ.

As a breastfeeding mom, I think it's pretty obvious that most of the asshole men that are posting on this thread do not have children.

Clearly no one in this thread was breastfed as a baby...

i tell you, it's not taking that long anymore and children will be required to be blindfolded when they are fed so that they cannot see the breasts they are sucking on.

:1orglaugh

I think the women post the pics to show family and friends...I know a lot of people that use Facebook as a way to share their photos with others, and not really for chatting :2 cents:

But, as many people have pointed out, Facebook is a private company and can do whatever they want, though the whole things seems a bit over the top.

It seems as though breast-feeding mothers are always on the crusade to fight for the right to breast feed in public, semi-public areas...

Uhm exactly where does it say Facebooks is for students only? This is from their company profile that THEY have on their website:

Website:
http://www.facebook.com/
Company Overview:
Facebook gives people the power to share and makes the world more open and connected.

Millions of people use Facebook everyday to keep up with friends, upload an unlimited number of photos, share links and videos, and learn more about the people they meet.

I don't see "students" anywhere in that text do you? Do you have a facebook account? I do, and I have hooked up with relatives I never knew I had, reconnected with the friends I used to hang out with in high school. While in the beginning facebook may have been directed at those in school, like many companies it has evolved into much more than that. You can find "fat people" on there, as well as "closed minded idiots" who have such little self esteem that they insist on playing keyboard warrior with trash talk in an effort to impress people about how cool they are"...mind you, the latter only gives rise to one question "is this person 18 yet because they sure sound like a 14 year old..certainly maturity must have kicked in by now"

I have no idea..

I breast fed my kids and I did NOT want anyone around staring at me or taking fucking pictures..let alone posting them all over the net.

Its not obscene.. but it should be a private bonding moment and feeding session for the child....not a "look at me, I'm breastfeeding" moment for the poor kid.

wow i love to watch breast feedings hahahahha

I think it's a great move... you can go to MySpace and show anything you want :Oh crap...

When are they going to ban pix of adults eating?

What kind of asshole woman puts up pictures of herself breast feeding? I know over 20 mothers and none of them I have ever even heard talk about breast feeding. Bottom line, if you are a "mother" and putting up breast feeding pictures you should have your kid taken away and you should receive a beating. What is next delivery room pics to "share with friends" fucking idiots... :disgust

I have children, but i also have a wife with enough class that I wouldnt have to worry about her posting breast feeding pics on facebook.

You have to be a total fucking retard to do that and think its normal.

One word comes to mind "Bitty"

that is pathetic. American companies are following on the footsteps of our ridiculous government. How sad!

Question - do they allow male nipples to be shown?

Good question. 5 college dudes blitzed out of their heads with shirts off raising their hands in triumph after the big game? Totally sexually explicit. To someone. Somewhere. With their own standards.

Whats obscene is that someone at facebook thinks a baby sucking a nipple is obsecne, sexually explicit, or anything but "big whoop".

And yet there are more fucked up things/photos. What the hell, they have to start with something

How about you read the TOS then?

" This Site is intended solely for users who are thirteen (13) years of age or older, and users of the Site under 18 who are currently in high school or college. Any registration by, use of or access to the Site by anyone under 13, or by anyone who is under 18 and not in high school or college, is unauthorized, unlicensed and in violation of these Terms of Use. By using the Service or the Site, you represent and warrant that you are 13 or older and in high school or college, or else that you are 18 or older, and that you agree to and to abide by all of the terms and conditions of this Agreement."

I dont care what you and your breastfeeding friends use Facebook for, but dont come crying when they ban your account

Whats that TOS supposed to be proving?

"or else that you are 18 or older"

case closed, lol.

:1orglaugh:1orglaugh:thumbsup

you know I'm the first to say fuck limiting freedom. But that is in society not a private company's property. Plus this comes down to common sense, if you take a picture of a friend eating and post that somewhere with his/her permission that's cool. The picture is maybe something funny to you both and it's just showing off the good time you and your friend had. It has purpose that does not involve you pushing some agenda or pushing your private life on unsuspecting friends/surfers. But if you post a picture of your own tit without the eaters permission because YOU want to show off that you have titties and are capable of reproducing (whoopdie doo) without thinking of the kids rights or even the rights of people who just don't want to see your nasty tit and some lil bastard suckin on it. YOU are wrong, the act is wrong. If every bitch I know showed me herself "breastfeeding" I would have jumped off a roof by now... furthermore I would have to think them all insane exhibitionists or simply drama queen attention whores... OH WAIT THAT'S 90% OF WOMEN :disgust

I seriously expected a more intilligent reply from you

I dont think that is to hard to understand. They are not telling you that its illegal for you to join if you are 18 or older, but that the site is intended solely for KIDS, and you should only join if you can agree that is the kind of community you want to support

If you want to build a breatfeeding network, you are free to do so, just dont their service

Again so what about the movement of "whole earth" mothers who enjoy not stuffing their child with the poison that is formula?

We don't have kids. I don't plan on having kids.

But breastfeeding is a beautiful thing... and I think promoting breastfeeding is wonderful because it will cut down on the instances of childhood allergies and other problems that you see children with because breastfeeding is much more natural and better for the child...

A girl can be a "student" at college and still be a mother and have children.... Being a mother doesn't mean she's not a student...

Your attitude stinks, ebus... it must suck that the only place in your life that you feel important enough to raise your voice is on adult message boards.. lol... You wouldn't have the balls to say half the shit you say on here... in person to someone.

Breastfeeding is a natural, beautiful thing... and plenty of men who spend time with their head out of the gutter are capable of making that distinction... maybe one day you will too.

My name is Kris - ebusdk is a domain

You are fucking clueless.. seriously borderline retarded. As I said, breastfeed all you want, and talk about all you want, but why the hell post personal breastfeeding images on a site designed for students. There is nothing wrong with promoting breastfeeding - All mothers should be breastfeeding as much as possible, but do it privately ffs. promoting breastfeeding is something you do in the right venue

re: raising my voice in public: I have been active in politics since the day I could vote, and I participate in the local and national political debate. I'm a member of a political party, so you can take you idiotic comment about me not having the balls to speak out in public, and shove it right up next to you own head that you have burried deep in your own ass

Facebook WAS a site for college students, it is NO LONGER just a site for college students.

And profiles are only viable by those you choose to let view them.

:1orglaugh:1orglaugh:1orglaugh

sorry if you took offense, but i think you misunderstood.

what i am surprised is the level of sudden exhibitionism people display over social network websites....i mean whats up with this? okay few pictures with your friends or your drunkness is fine, but how far do we need to go ?

What the hell? How can you not understand the text you are quoting?

The text very clearly says the site is intended for the two following groups:
- anyone over 18
- anyone between 13 and 18 who is currently in high school or college

How can you not get that? It says so in very plain English.

Its YOU who cant read moron.

How fucking hard is it to understand? do I need to cut it out one line at the time?


#1
= intended for people between 13 and 18 and in school

#2
= no matte what age you are, you can join - AS LONG AS your actions and what you publish fits what they see fit for the site demographic


So does that mean you should make a Breastfeeding group or image archive? Take a wild fucking guess. Go to myspace if you want to network about you adult interests, but let the fucking kids and other student have their facebook in peace ffs

Eh, no. It means intended for people over 13, and of those who are over 13 but under 18, only those who are in high school or college.

Seriously, you're dumb :2 cents:

ohh, so when they say

They dont actually mean


But instead
Now how about that. I wish I was as smart as you.

idiot

sorry have to bring in some comic relief

http://i119.photobucket.com/albums/o...etToughGuy.jpg
http://pds5.egloos.com/pds/200701/26...8_09014845.jpg

why not? two natural private acts that should be kept to ones self. Stupid women think they are something special to behold. No one cares morons, you either have a penis or a vagina. GET THE FUCK OVER IT! :disgust