heath ledger was NOT that good in the dark knight
 

at all....

jack played a much better joker... if they give the award to heath I'll be pissed...

they need to give it to RDJ baby tropic thunder.....

WTF is that

looks like a small tit

Dude... you are SO wrong... on both!!!!

he rocked as the joker... nicholas was good, but too..... 1980s :upsidedow

tropic thunder - completely sucked... whats sad is the only cool part in it is when Cruise makes his appearance( and I fucking HAAAAAATE tom cruise)... the rest of that movie is complete shit...

id squeeze that fucker with a pair of vice grips

gotta agree, dark knight was pure hype. the studio probably cried teared of joys when they heard he offed himself. ridiculous publicity.

The Dark Knight sucked. Ledger was the BEST joker. His best acting was in Brokeback Mountain, he should have got the Oscar then.

im a little worried about that dood you need to get that checked... the fuck happen? spider bite?

im just talking best supporting actor....

heath was shit in the movie... jack was way better joker.... in tropic thunder which was not the best movie I agree but Robert Downey played a great role.. if you ask me he stole the show....

just on best supporting actor alone... is all im judging.....

I was so not impressed with heath at all..... Tom did play a great part in that movie though.....

If you watch the Tim Burton Batman now, you realize it's not a great movie. I'm a fan of Burton and Nicholson, and the new versions blow the old out of the water.

But that's just my opinion.

Sorry you're wrong, Heath was better on every level

He will get an oscar for his performance in dark knight. Even if it wasn't an oscar worthy performance, the film association will give it to him just for the sake of his legacy. I think he made a damn good joker. Oscar worthy? Not sure, Jack did a HELL of a job and I don't think he got an oscar. Heath was a good actor though.

He was very good at Dark Knight

no offense to your influence on movies, but... heath was not a supporting actor in this one... christian was...

jack was about a zillion times better than heath ledger but people are such little pussies theyll never admit to it

i thought the movie sucked, there were better batmans (esp 1)

Ill have to watch it again to make sure im not wrong, but the only cooler thing about the 1st joker was the big ass gun he yanked out of his trousers....

That was awesome!!!

Im dreading the next batman though...

Check the cast for the upcoming batan, you will cry...

The guy was outstanding much better than Jack

nothing special

Agreed :thumbsup

I watched the two burton movies on tv a week ago and there just weren't that great, especially when compared to the Nolan movies.

Jack Nicholson's role was goofy and fun, Heath Ledgers was true to the comics.

I just spent 45 minutes on that site http://www.popthatzit.com/

Apples and oranges between Jack and Heath on thier portrayal of the Joker. they were 2 Different Writers versions of the joker. Jack played the 70's Style of joker. where heath played the Frank miller Version(personally i like Millers Batman Series better)

the oscars are retarded

Please Heath was much much better

It's a comic book movie!!! and that was far before they became popular as well. Now they try so hard to make the characters to seem cool and dark that theres barely any character left! IE new Punisher movie...

I Like both the tim burton batmans and the new ones but ledgers performance was never anything special, it was just well done and over blown because he died from not being able to read prescription warnings...

Jack was gold!

not according to the awards....

Yeah but you can't say the JOKER isn't supposed to be a JOKER

After all he is the JOKER

Not that this topic hasn't be covered a hundred times before... and thanks for being so original, but let me repost what I had said about this once already....

--------------------

I hated Nicholson's Joker... but people praised him, said his performance could not be improved upon.

He was a good actor, but a terrible Joker. It's not his fault though, it's what the movie makers wanted. They did his make up, wrote the words, put him in those clothes.

The Joker didn't use knock out gas... he used poison gas. He didn't leave cards that could be analyzed, he left cards that blew up! He didn't trap people to kill them in some contraption.... he shot them between the eyes.

He's a serial killer... and what they did to his character for tv and the movies and the even the comics for a while was terrible.

But I guess it all came at a time when people didn't want their kids reading about that. It was too..... "dark".

They try to give him the Oscar because of his death.He was a very talented actor and I am sorry that he died so young.He would have been a more appreciated talent in time

Im with you on this. Ledger made the Dark Knight.

I don't even know how you can compare the two performances when the only similarity in the characters is the name. Personally I think Ledgers Joker was much closer to what I think the joker should be like were he real. That said, when the first batman came out they were trying to appeal to kids more than anything and therefore needed to have a significantly less sinister and dark joker. The only thing you can really compare between the two is the acting, and in that I believe that Ledger did the better job as Nicholson was much more comical than serious in his portrayal. That however, I think is in large part due to the writing and directing.

Remember, it's only entertainment...

are you pissed? cause heath just won

I'd rather look at 2girls1cup than that.... Am I normal? :Oh crap

you=retard

yep heath played a very intense maniac. he carried that film imo

well of course not...

Im talking about the people...


FOR THE PEOPLE!!!!

I want to pop that thing so bad!

Jew Cat FTW!

He wasn't that good, yet he wins

Personally, I liked Heath's Joker a whole lot better than Jack's. However they weren't playing the same character; one was in the style of Adam West's goofy foe, while the other was the crazed psychotic who kills Robin in The Killing Joke. I also agree with the above that Heath shouldn't have been a supporting actor in that film; I'm a Bale fan but his work in Dark Knight was pretty poor - I could have watched Heath cause chaos for hours though :2 cents:

Not a heath ledger fan at all and don't want to take anything away from Jack but the most recent Joker was the best by far.

Whoever says he wasnt good, have no clue about acting....he was amazing in Dark Night.....true he did the drugs but still , it was natural...

Heath Ledger made that role his own. Amazing work. RIP Heath. Congrats on the Oscar!

My pinky toe knows more about acting than most do....


I could give a fuck about the drugs to each his own.... heath was a talented actor I never said he was not...

all I was saying is he was not the best joker... IMO jack was a better joker...

truthfully it was nice he won... his family now has something and his daughter has a nice toy to have on her shelf now....

I was speaking on acting alone...

he was not that good in the dark knight .... some disagree some agree... has nothing to do with what I know about acting and what I don't know about acting... I'm willing to bet ive been around more actors, directors, and movie sets , tv sets than you have... I know a thing or 2 about acting....



oh well

congrats Heath and congrats to all the winners.....

Is there anything you're not better at than other people Danza?

For such a dumb fucking idiot you got a lot of ego going on.

oh tons of shit dood.....

im not god or anything


fact I know something your better at than I am.... thats letting my mouth write checks my ass can't cash.....


what is it about 9am over there right now franck... enjoy lunch brother :) and have a fun evening hahahahahaha

I just watched the movie today, watched Batman Begins last night. Batman Begins is a much better movie. Heath did a great job, not oscar worthy though.

Your PI is gonna attack me this evening? Or poison my food? What is it today?

Do you understand why people think you're really fucked in your head?

You are saying i should watch my food and that i have a PI on my ass because i called you an dumb fuck on the interwebs a couple of times. Do you have any idea how insane that sounds? You don't do you?

PI's don't attack dickweed... they gather intel...

I never said i'd poison your food....

I thought for your safety we were going to go to neutral corners franck? don't that sound like the best idea? you really want to keep this going? according to you I thought you were smarter than that? some of your post you show a tiny bit of intelligence it surprises me that you want to keep this going after you have been warned a few times.....

you back off ill back off it's very simple....


you have been warned twice now.... if you really want to tempt faith keep it going.... not the smartest thing to do bro....

your nothing to me but a pimple to pop....

seriously

ill ask again.. for a 3rd time....

back off

I know more about you and your family than you do at this point.... so seriously back off and ill back off it's that simple... I don't know any other way to say it....

Well we all know what you mean when you say stuff like watch what you eat you fucking moron.

So let's say i will keep you a fucking moron because you are a fucking moron. What are you gonna do? You seriously are so fucking retarded that you can't understand this is a fucking messageboard? You know as soon as i close this browser you don't exist. If you seriously think i would waste 2 secs irl on you then you're even more stupid than i already thought you are.

So anyway maybe you should do the same. It's really beyond pathetic the stuff you come up with with your pi's and telling me to watch what i eat etc. It will only result in even more people calling you a fucking moron. Can't you fucking understand that moron?